Acute anxiety: Internet searches for key words spiked to all-time high early in pandemic
he recent uptick in anxiety-related searches online could help
build the case for more targeted mental health interventions, researchers said
in a new study released Monday.
(CNN)As the coronavirus
pandemic gained traction in the United States, internet searches for key words
related to panic attacks and acute anxiety spiked.
Google searches for
anxiety symptoms from mid-March to mid-May were the highest they've been in the
history of the search engine, according to researchers at the Qualcomm
Institute's Center for Data Driven Health at the University of California San
Diego.
The study was published Monday in the Journal of the American
Medical Association.
In particular, anxiety and panic attack searches corresponded to
major news events, including March 16, when social distancing guidelines were
put in place nationally; and March 29, when those guidelines were extended.
Queries also spiked on April 3, when US President Donald Trump
announced face mask recommendations; and on April 11, when the US surpassed
Italy in the number of coronavirus deaths.
The results could give leaders and policy makers perspective on
how to manage the general population's perception
of public health directives, and could inform how we empower those in crisis to
seek help quickly, researchers
said.
"For some, fear has a greater adverse effect on their
health than Covid does," said John Ayers, lead author of the study and
adjunct associate professor at San Diego State University. "The results
can help leaders listen and think holistically about the cost of some of those
measures."
Timely insight into the nation's mood
Researchers monitored how often people searched phrases such as
"panic attack," "anxiety attack," "am I having a panic
attack?", "signs of anxiety attack" and "anxiety attack
symptoms."
The scientists compared the total number of anxiety-related
searches during the early days of the pandemic with data reaching back to
January 2004, and they adjusted for variables such as population growth and
increased internet use over the past two decades.
Compared with where the trend on these search terms had been
headed prior to the pandemic, the research team said they believe that the
crisis caused an 11% increase in searches related to panic attacks during the
58-day period.
"In practical terms, over the first 58 days of the Covid-19
pandemic there were an estimated 3.4 million total searches related to severe
acute anxiety in the United States," said Benjamin Althouse, an affiliate
assistant professor at the University of Washington, and a collaborator on the
study.
"Searches for anxiety and panic attacks were the highest
they've ever been in over 16 years of historical search data."
The highest overall day was March 28, a day before social
distancing guidelines were extended, in which anxiety searches were 52% higher
than expected, had there not been a pandemic.
This study comes a week after the US Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention published survey data showing a spike in the
number of people reporting increased substance abuse and seriously considering
suicide, a trend that was similarly
pronounced as well in the Black and Latino communities.
The CDC's report included a startling statistic that one in four people ages 18 through 24 had
reported suicidal thoughts in the 30 days preceding the survey.
How to better help people in crisis
This new data could help officials design interventions that
directly benefit a person in the midst of a panic attack, and it can help
researchers target where and when heightened emotional stress is taking place.
Using search engine results can give a more real-time insight to
meet people where they are, as compared with more traditional research methods
such as doing a telephone survey or enrolling participants into a study, Ayers
explained.
"Listening to the public can have a direct impact,"
Ayers said. "We see people expressing a need and seeking help. Internet
search is also a pathway for intervention."
He and his team
highlighted Illinois' Call4Calm hotline, rolled out by the state's Department of
Human Services' Division of Mental Health to provide anonymous
support to people experiencing emotional stress and mental health issues during
the Covid-19 crisis.
"This can be
scaled up," he said.
Another way to deploy
public health resources where people can access them most immediately, might be
to use existing search tools, such as Google's OneBox, to prioritize
information that can help in emergencies, the researchers argued.
The OneBox feature,
which the search giant often uses to highlight news, shopping or image results,
is used to prominently display the phone number for the National Suicide
Prevention Lifeline, 1-800-273-8255, above other search results if
someone inputs a suicide-related search query.
Know the signs and what to do
You may be having a panic attack if you're feeling a fast or
irregular heartbeat, chest pain, dizziness, headaches or a loss of appetite,
according to the National Health Service in the United
Kingdom.
Emotional signs of a panic attack include symptoms such as feeling
tense or nervous, worrying about the past or future, feeling tearful and not
being able to sleep or relax.
If you're experiencing panic attack symptoms, the NHS recommends
calm breathing practices, getting enough exercise, eating a healthy diet, seeking
out peer support and using a mindfulness or meditation app.
Mental health experts
also say that it can be useful to practice gratitude and establish a schedule.
Especially during the coronavirus crisis, it's important to be careful with how
and when you engage with the media, if news is driving your anxiety. And
limiting social media use can help too, as they can spread misinformation and
conspiracy theories about the virus.
"A panic attack
is not to be taken lightly as it can land someone in the emergency room with
shortness of breath, a pounding heart, chest pain, and an intense feeling of
fear," Ayers said. "Our results unquestionably warrant a need for
increased mental health services."
CNN's Sandee LaMotte
contributed to this story.